I’ve come across that idea before too, and while its scientific validity is a little shaky, it’s such a fascinating way to imagine the difference in how dogs and cats perceive us. Dogs, being pack animals with a long history of domestication, seem to have evolved to recognize humans as distinct partners, allies, and leaders. They’re wired to read our faces, follow our pointing, understand our tone, and pick up on body language in ways that go far beyond what they do with other dogs. In a sense, they know we aren’t dogs—but they still consider us part of their family “pack.” It’s one of the reasons dogs can respond so intuitively to commands and emotions; they recognize that we are “other,” but important.
advertisement
Cats, on the other hand, don’t have that same evolutionary partnership. Their domestication history is shorter and more self-directed—they decided to live alongside humans because it benefited them, not necessarily because they wanted to form deep social bonds in the same way dogs did. That’s why some behaviorists speculate that cats might not fully distinguish us from themselves. They may treat us the way they’d treat another cat—albeit a very large, clumsy, fur-less one. For instance, when a cat rubs against your leg, kneads your lap, or even brings you “gifts” like a dead mouse, it could be them using the same social signals they would with another feline. It’s less about recognizing us as another species, and more about slotting us into their world using the framework they already understand.
So when a cat gives you that completely blank stare, it’s funny to think maybe they’re looking at you the way they’d look at an incompetent fellow cat. Like: “Why are you so bad at grooming yourself? Where’s your tail? Why can’t you land properly after a jump? You really are the weirdest cat I’ve ever seen.” That would explain why some cats act so indifferent—they’re just unimpressed by our lack of proper feline skills. Dogs, meanwhile, might be more like, “This human isn’t a dog, but they’re something special and I’ll follow them anywhere.”
Whether or not that’s scientifically true, it’s a charming way to frame the differences in how our furry companions see us—and it says a lot about why dogs and cats connect with people in such unique, but equally meaningful, ways.
advertisement
Watch Video Below